Andrew Johnson: The most-criticized president ever?

Today marks the anniversary of the passing of Andrew Johnson, perhaps the most-criticized president in American history. But was Johnson really that bad a president, or just the target of some second-guessing historians?

Andrew_JohnsonJohnson died from a stroke on July 31, 1875 while visiting his daughter in Tennessee, just months into what he hoped was a political comeback.

Johnson had the unfortunate task of succeeding Abraham Lincoln after the 16th president’s assassination.  Although first popular,  Johnson’s term in office went downhill quickly and he barely avoided conviction in the Senate after he was impeached by the House.

But historians didn’t regard Johnson has a truly poor president until well after his death in 1875.

Johnson was born in 1808 in North Carolina. He served in the Senate and the House and as governor, and then military governor, of Tennessee. It was when he was serving as military governor that Lincoln asked him to replace Hannibal Hamlin as vice president in the 1864 campaign. A Democrat, Johnson switched parties for the election.

Already an enigma because of his well-known independent streak and his earlier support of slavery, Johnson turned heads when he was possibly drunk at his own inauguration in 1865. (Another theory was that Johnson was ill, since he hadn’t been known for drinking in public.)

Johnson suddenly found himself as president when Lincoln died just after starting his second term. His policies during Reconstruction were controversial and caused his new-found party to impeach him in 1868. Johnson kept his job by one vote in a Senate trial.

In his official biography on the White House website, Johnson’s term is summed up politely.

“Although an honest and honorable man, Andrew Johnson was one of the most unfortunate of presidents. Arrayed against him were the Radical Republicans in Congress, brilliantly led and ruthless in their tactics. Johnson was no match for them,” says a bio prepared by Michael Beschloss and Hugh Sidey.

Looking back at how historians who have ranked Johnson (and other presidents) since 1948, he appears to be the one president who has suffered most at the hands of revisionist history—either because more facts are available about his term, or because his place in the history of race relations has been re-evaluated.

In 1948, historian Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr. ranked Johnson as a middle-of-the-pack president: a respectable 19th out of 29 presidents.

Since then, some presidents have risen in the eyes of historians, like James K. Polk and Andrew Jackson.

Andrew Johnson’s ratings have plummeted like a rock. In a recent 2010 Siena College survey, Johnson was called the worst president in history. A 2011 survey from a British academic institute ranked Johnson as 36th out of 40 presidents.

Johnson has been tossed into the bottom rung of presidents, including James Buchanan (who served before Lincoln), Franklin Pierce (who preceded Buchanan), and Warren Harding.

In Johnson’s case, Lincoln was a tough act to follow, and Johnson’s failed role in obstructing much of the GOP’s Reconstruction plans was a tough pill for historians to swallow.

After becoming president, Johnson fought with his own Cabinet and party members over the scope of readmitting secessionist states and the voting rights of blacks.

Johnson favored a very lenient version of Reconstruction and state control over who could vote, according to their race. He also openly opposed the 14th Amendment.

Although Johnson had supported an end to slavery in the 1860s, he was a white supremacist. “This is a country for white men, and by God, as long as I am President, it shall be a government for white men,” he wrote in 1866.

In the end, the Radical Republicans won control over Reconstruction and Johnson became a pariah.

Johnson vetoed the Civil Rights Bill, but Congress overrode the veto in an unprecedented move.

Somehow, Johnson survived the impeachment trial, possibly because there was no vice president to replace him, and moderates feared Benjamin Wade, the Senate president pro tempore who would have replaced Johnson.

The Radical Republicans also eventually failed, and Reconstruction had ended within a decade. Racial discrimination continued on into the middle of the following century.

Johnson is also known for another historical footnote: He was the only former president to be elected to the U.S. Senate.

In 1875, Johnson ran for his old Senate seat from Tennessee (after failing in tries for the Senate in 1869 and the House in 1872). He won after a state convention that featured 56 ballots.

Former President Johnson was sworn in by the same Senate that almost impeached him a few years earlier. After serving about four months in the Senate, he passed away.

Recent Historical Stories

Happy 56th Birthday, NASA!

World War I starts, America watches and worries

10 fascinating facts on the Postal Service’s birthday

FDR’s third-term decision and the 22nd amendment